Hold onto your hats, baseball fans, because Freddie Freeman has once again been crowned the best first baseman in Major League Baseball (MLB) by MLB Network’s infamous ‘Shredder’ ranking system. But here’s where it gets controversial—how does a 36-year-old player continue to dominate a position where hitting is king, and young stars are constantly knocking on the door? Let’s dive in.
Being a top-tier first baseman in MLB is no small feat. It’s a position where offensive prowess is paramount, and even the slightest dip in performance can cost you playing time. Yet, Freddie Freeman has not only survived but thrived for 17 years, consistently ranking among the best hitters in the league, let alone at first base. With an impressive resume boasting 2,431 hits, 547 doubles, and 367 home runs, Freeman’s longevity and productivity are nothing short of remarkable.
On Monday, MLB Network unveiled its annual top-10 first basemen list, and for the third consecutive season, Freeman claimed the top spot. And this is the part most people miss—while the ‘Shredder’ rankings often spark debate among fans and analysts, Freeman’s reign at the top is hard to dispute. Here’s the full list for context:
- Freddie Freeman
- Nick Kurtz
- Matt Olson
- Bryce Harper
- Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
- Rafael Devers
- Yandy Diaz
- Pete Alonso
- Michael Busch
- Willson Contreras
This lineup is stacked with talent, but Freeman’s ability to post elite numbers at his age is what sets him apart. Since joining the Dodgers after 12 seasons with the Atlanta Braves, he’s made five straight All-Star appearances and secured a 2020 NL MVP title. His OPS+ over the past three seasons? 163 in 2023, followed by 141 in both 2024 and 2025. Bold statement alert—Freeman’s consistency is the secret sauce that silences even his harshest critics.
Of course, no MLB ranking is without its controversies. Nick Kurtz landing at No. 2 raises eyebrows, given his limited experience, and some argue that Matt Olson or Vladimir Guerrero Jr. deserve higher spots. But Freeman’s track record—leading the NL in doubles four times, runs three times, and maintaining a lifetime .300 batting average—makes it tough to deny his supremacy. In today’s game, where such milestones are increasingly rare, Freeman’s achievements stand out even more.
So, what’s next for Freeman in 2026? Only time will tell, but history suggests he’s far from done. Here’s the thought-provoking question for you—is Freddie Freeman’s dominance a testament to his unparalleled skill, or does it highlight the lack of consistent competition at first base? Let us know your thoughts in the comments—we’re eager to hear your take!
